Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dan's avatar

Hey Matt, a good selection of interesting stuff as usual. I enjoyed the Early Adopter article in particular. Also looking forward to reading the Jamie Briswick article and maybe relistening to that episode again. Driving through Malibu last summer, the devastation still evident was an eye-opener. (Guided by my copy of Looking Sideways vol 1, naturally!)

Tim LeRoy's avatar

I wrote a very long comment after Alex Roddie and James Carson's debate last year, and most of that still stands absolutely.

I am still choosing to avoid using AI as much as possible.

Dr Len’s posts on his use of AI are interesting, provocative and have challenged my own thinking, particularly around intersectional issues. The (few) genuinely compelling use-cases for AI tools that I’ve seen are for equity and access. When you are, like me, in a position of considerable privilege it’s important to read the perspectives of people like Dr Len.

I think he is right in nearly everything he says, but despite his ‘I am an actual expert in this - I dare you to challenge me’ he’s missing a great deal, and skims over very brief mentions of counter-arguements as if they have no real merit. He seems to be dismissing the moral and environmental arguments because now anyone can build very niche apps.

In the article you linked to this week, he makes the point that early adopters get to lead how the future is built.

There’s the rub. Early adopters like Zuckerberg, Bezos, Altman, Musk et al? A lovely bunch of chaps.

I believe that AI technologies are unconscionable for environmental and moral reasons, but mostly for democratic reasons.

‘We the people’ have no representation. We have no say over who owns them and who profits from them. We have no oversight, nor control of how they are built, tested, deployed nor used. Our representatives in parliament and congress are either powerless or bought, and you can read Carole Cadwalladr to see how that’s playing out.

Although I’ll keep reading people like Dr Len I think the bad will outweigh the good in the short-term. The future is built upon the rubble of what stands now.

2 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?